Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Putnam Record Insurance There are many changes happening in the insurance industry today. Major companies like GEICO and Progressive are trying to sell insurance coverage in a pre-packaged way, like a happy meal from McDonalds.

But we've heard stories from customers who were with those other companies, that when you have to file a claim for service, you get the run around and delays. This happens because every time you call , you are dealing with a different person on the phone, and they don't know your situation or your history. They are just looking at a screen with your billing information and a profitability indicator which tells them how long they should be on the phone helping you.

Well we've made a good living helping local people with their insurance using the personal touch. We don't use profitability measurements to determine how long we will help you with your business. We stick with you and finish the job until you are satisfied.

We've been providing insurance coverage for over 75 years, and we've learned all the secrets in this industry, so we know how to give you the best of both worlds: Getting you quality insurance coverage, at a low price you can afford.
Served areas
  • Western New York Region
Highlights and features
  • Insurance bonds fidelity surety dunkirk fredonia car truck business home workers comp compensation
Associations and certifications
  • CPCU
Services
No two people are the same, so why would you want someone else's insurance strategy? After all, with different careers, life path, and goals, you need coverage tailored to your situation. That's why we seek to simplify the complex, while also providing a level of service rarely seen in the insurance industry.
Here at Putnam Record Insurance Agency we know what matters most to you, but it's complicated to know what type of insurance you need, how much is enough, and which company has the best coverage. That's why thousands of people rely on the Putnam Record Insurance Agency to guide them through the insurance maze.
Our reasons for becoming insurance professionals are deeply personal. We live here, we work here, and we are committed to our community. We feel insurance shouldn't be confusing, so we try to simplify the process by spending time discussing coverages with you so that you can be better prepared for the future.
Our mission is to get to know and understand your needs, wants, and long-term goals. We want to help you develop, implement, and monitor a strategy that's designed to address your unique situation. The world can be an unpredictable place. Our commitment is to utilize all our resources to help you pursue your goals and help you keep those who matter most, safe. We believe in thinking "out of the box, " and we are not afraid to challenge conventional wisdom in our approach to insurance and protection.
While we currently do not have any open positions at our office we are always considering adding to our team if it is the right fit. If you email me your resume and references I will review it for consideration. It's a good feeling to work in a place where people believe in what they're doing. At Putnam Record Agency, we are committed to bringing passion and customer focus to the business of insurance.
People
Doug Mahany
Doug Mahany
Owner
I've been protecting people with high quality low cost insurance for over 20 years, carrying on the legacy of our founder William Putnam who started the agency over 75 years ago. My goal is to make sure you are properly protected at a fair price that you can afford.
Reviews (12)
Write a Review
Bruce Ritenburg Iii
Jun 28, 2022
I have always been satisfied with the quick service and knowledgeable, professional people at Putnam Record Insurance Agency for all of my insurance needs.
James Watson
May 16, 2022
They put forth extra effort and make sure that you understand the details.very patient and pleasant people to work with. I believe they got me the best deal possible.
Cindy Maring
Feb 25, 2022
I'm very happy with the service I received from the Putnam Agency. They review your needs and find you a reasonable priced policy to full fill it. I personally dealt with Danielle and found her very knowledgeable and able to handle my needs.
Robert Kaus
Feb 10, 2022
Great people and easy to work with. They helped me lower my car insurance by lowering my yearly mileage after I retired.
Lisa Parla Loeb
Feb 22, 2021
I highly recommend Putnam Record Insurance for all of your insurance needs! The entire staff is amazing especially Maggie and Danielle - always helpful - always caring and kind!
Dale VanVlack
Nov 06, 2020
Putnam was such a pleasure to do business with. They saved me a lot of money. I would highly recommend them to anyone!
Marta Uszacki
Oct 29, 2020
I have used Putnam Insurance for many years and would recommend Putnam to anyone looking for insurance. The women are extremely nice and are always there to answer your questions and return your calls. I will continue to do business with Putnam for years to come.
Fred DiPalma
Oct 22, 2020
I have nothing but good things to say about Putnam Insurance, working with Maggie Owen for my home and auto insurance was very pleasant and I knew she went above a beyond to get me the best service and price. I also purchased supplemental insurance for my Medicare plan from Danielle Marx who was very thorough and patient with my many questions. I feel I got the best plans on both home, auto and health insurance I would highly recommend Putnam for all your insurance needs.
Dawn Hedges
Jun 09, 2020
I have been using this company for almost 20 years! They have always had my best interest in mind and take the time to explain the differences in policies and plans. They have always taken initiative to shop for the most cost effective quotes for me without compromising the quality of my coverage. Putnam Record Agency has the knowledge and bandwidth to offer a large number of options and coverages but has never lost sight of individual customer experience and maintaining the personalized connection. They even send personalized greeting cards!
Jan Dekoff
Jul 27, 2018
The Putnam Record Agency has been wonderful to work with. I have enjoyed working with Doug, Danielle, and Maggie. They are easy to work with and responsive to all of our business needs!
Ruth Deike
Jul 11, 2018
We've been with this agency for many years and have never been disappointed. Highly recommend.
Nicholas Bellanti
Jul 10, 2018
The people at Putnam Record Insurance Agency have deep care for their clients. Their customer service is second to none, and it is a pleasure to deal with them. I work with Maria and she is a pleasure to speak to.