Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
A-1-A All Risk Agency For over 80 years, our family is committed to delivering expert advice and courteous service. Licensed in Ohio and surrounding states, we are a "full service" agency. All of your insurance needs can be met at Kelly Insurance. Our goal is to create customers for life by meeting and exceeding your expectations with every interaction. Have a conversation with us!

It only takes a moment to learn who we are and how this attitude of service is simply our fabric. It's why we're here. It's what we do! Whatever your need, we can provide a solution.
Follow us
Services
For over 80 years now, Kelly Insurance has proudly served Cuyahoga Falls and surrounding communities. We specialize in personal lines insurance (like auto, home, and motorcycle). And we also have a dedicated team for business owners and commercial insurance needs. As one of only a few genuine "full service" insurance agencies in the state, rest assured that your risk is safe with us.
They say it is bad to assume. But if you have a risk, it is actually safe to assume that Kelly Insurance has a solution for you. From the most preferred auto & home bundle to the worst driving record in history, we have a solution. And, sorry to sound conceited, we're good at it. We consistently deliver low cost, high quality products for every risk.
Reviews (12)
Write a Review
Serinna Law
May 07, 2022
Been with them for years and they are always there for us whenever we call, e-mail, etc! They get back to us in a timely manner. Tanya is amazing and is always there for us when we we have questions big or small. She makes changing anything on our policy easy or shopping around simple. They take the stress away! Would highly recommend!
D. Geo
Feb 06, 2022
They're the best! Tonya is always pleasant and a joy to work with. You are greatly appreciated. David
Tim Cole
Jul 04, 2021
Very friendly atmosphere will get you the best rates possible I love working with Dave thanks Dave
Phil Pavarini Jr
May 03, 2021
I've been an insurance agent for closer to two decades than one. I've had occasion to work with many other insurance agencies. Rarely have I run across an agency more interested in helping the client than Kelly Insurance Agency. Thank you.
Kelly Casterline
Apr 18, 2021
Chad from Kelly insurance was the biggest help in the process of buying a new home! He helped me chose a new insurance company, gave very helpful information and advice and also completely handled an issue the title company we had to deal with caused. He took all the stress out of being a first time home buyer and I would highly suggest anyone chose Kelly insurance to handle all of their needs!
Bill Lowery Realtor
Apr 02, 2021
Have used them for cars and my home for years. Very responsive and looking to get me in the right product.
Nick Hammerschmidt
May 06, 2020
Chad and the team are awesome. I am a very difficult customer and the team at Kelly Insurance treated me extremely well. They responded to my many questions quickly. Chad found me an amazing deal on my homeowners and auto insurance. I highly recommend Kelly Insurance.
Jade Green
Mar 26, 2020
They're awesome! Tom J. just helped me out of a huge pinch. He was able to address a rather complicated situation very quickly. He prioritized me, as a customer, and kept me well informed throughout the resolution process. Kelly Insurance is reliable, professional, and I trust them entirely!
Tracy
Dec 22, 2019
Great resource for your insurance needs. Very helpful and will work to get you the best rates for all types of insurance. Highly recommend!
Shane Kagey
Nov 18, 2018
Been dealing with them for years, they are truly amazing, so caring and professional, I can't say enough good things about them! Chad is unbelievable. I honestly can't believe how friendly and thorough he is, He is an absolute pleasure to work with. I would never go anywhere else! The guy that rated them 1 star, has to be crazy (he must be reviewing a different Company)
Mark Snyder
Jan 03, 2018
I have been insured with The Kelly Insurance Agency continuously for over 43 years. They make all insurance matters very easy for me. Recently, they went beyond what was expected to help me in a difficult situation. They never hesitated to spend the extra time. The outcome was to my benefit, and it took very little effort on my part. I highly recommend the Kelly Insurance Agency. I'm glad I found them back in 1974!
Mark
Jul 14, 2016
I have used Kelly Insurance for decades. Through the years after moving away, and return to Ohio, I shopped insurance and couldn't find a more knowledgable group that actively looks for ways to save you money. How many companies do you know will call you to ask if it's okay to switch you to another company because they were reviewing your policy and found a way to reduce your premiums? Kelly has done that on several occasions over the years.

When you have a claim they are also there. I recently had a $130,000.00 fire claim, they walked me through the process, as my advocate. Then, after the loss, finding ways to retain homeowners insurance at the best possible rate. I use them for all my business and personal insurance. Thank you, to the entire Kelly group, it's refreshing. Mark S.