Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Starr-Mathews Agency We are an independent agency servicing North Georgia and Tennessee since 1920. We are focused on making sure your home, car, health, life or business needs are adequately covered and placed with the best insurance company for your situation. As part of our CUSTOMER ACCOUNT REVIEW EXPERIENCE, we'll perform a complete account analysis of all your policies every year at renewal, without any hassle to you. Because we're not tied to a single insurance company, we can shop around for you to find the best insurance plan for your needs.
Services
Starr-Mathews Agency, Inc. is a locally-owned independent insurance agency serving clients in Georgia and Tennessee. The principals include James S. Mathews, W. Craig Mashburn, Robert H. Mathews and W. Barton Mathews. This agency has been built on a solid foundation of integrity, honesty, and hard work.
Auto insurance is absolutely essential for every driver. You need to be sure that you have high quality auto insurance that offers the appropriate amount of coverage to protect yourself and others if you are in an accident. Car insurance is about more than just finding the lowest price. We all know that while price is important, you need to be sure that you are getting the best coverage for that price.
Who can deny the freedom you feel when riding your motorcycle? Motorcycle owners take great pride in their motorcycles - and whether you ride a classic Harley, a racing bike, or a moped, you need to protect yourself by taking appropriate safety precautions, including having the right insurance coverage.
Are you getting ready to hit the road in your RV or camper? Before you go, make sure you have the appropriate insurance. Georgia and Tennessee recreational vehicle insurance is necessary to protect you when you are traveling in your motor home, camper or motor coach. Recreational vehicles, or RVs, include a wide range of motor homes, campers, bus conversions and more.
Reviews (3)
Write a Review
Paul Chase
Feb 25, 2022
Stay away from this insurance company nothing but incompetence and waste of time no ever knows what's going on. My agent is always out of the office has wasted endless hours of my time not mention a had to proceed with legal action against them because they refuse to pay out money legally owed to me and ignoring me. Absolutely horrific terrible customer service stay far away from this office.
Teddy Kellogg
Dec 24, 2020
I tried contacting and leaving messages with several agencies. Starr Mathews Agency was the only one that returned my call. They made sure I had the best policy for my business.
Lisa Davis
Nov 23, 2015
Melody in their office is rude, unprofessional, no personality at all. My family called about coverage for their business. They stated she was the most unprofessional person they have dealt with. They ask questions about coverage that she could not answer. My family felt nervous about purchasing insurance with someone they did not have a good feeling about.

They ask for someone else and Melody stated I can help so my family hung up and called back. They informed the agency of this issue and was told we will handle but never heard back.