As an independent insurance agency, we work for you, not the insurance carriers. That means we can help you find the best value on auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, and more from several of New York's most trusted carriers.

Update Share

Why an Independent Agent Report

Because independent insurance agencies, like Coyle Insurance Agency, Inc., represent a number of different insurance companies, and can compare coverage and prices to find the best possible value for your individual circumstances. As independent agents, we are members of the Congers community, and we're committed to doing business face-to-face and being your advocate in times of need. Here are a few reasons why Coyle Insurance Agency, Inc. should be your first and last stop when looking for insurance.

Insurance Report

Coyle Insurance Agency, Inc. is an independent insurance agency, which means we do business with multiple insurance companies and compare protection and prices to find the best value for you. We're not computers, we are real, live members of the Congers community, and we're committed to being your advocate in times of need. To talk with one of our helpful team members about your insurance needs, request a free quote or call us at 845-268-7000 today.

Vehicle Report

As an independent insurance agency, Coyle Insurance Agency, Inc. works with many insurance companies and can help you compare protection and prices to find the coverage and value that's right for you. We're your local agents - real, live members of the Congers community, so we know how to get the right insurance for your vehicle.

Auto Report

The right auto insurance policy can help get you back on the road quickly if your car is damaged or destroyed by accident, fire, theft, or other covered event. Your policy may also provide protection against medical and legal expenses resulting from injury, loss of life, or property damage caused by an accident involving your vehicle.

Kimberley Curti

Jan 06, 2022

Report

Stephen and Jeannine and team are always accessible, all-the-while being friendly, and efficient. True professionals that are happy to share their experience and expertise. A refreshing and welcomed rarity in many companies these days.

Daniel D'Auria

Sep 20, 2021

Report

They were extremely knowledgeable & helpful. They explained everything, made sure I had everything covered & got me the best rate for what i needed. I would highly recommend them to family & friends. Thank you Coyle Insurance Agency.

David N.

May 29, 2021

Report

I made a great choice of insurance agencies when I switched to Coyle last year. Every agent and staff person that I have had an opportunity to speak with was knowledgeable and efficient. After many years as a CPA in public accounting I appreciate and value these traits. I regret not having found the Coyle Insurance Agency and these great people earlier in my career.

Rick'S. Club American - Pan Partners

Feb 22, 2021

Report

Coyle Insurance always goes above and beyond, while providing the best service and insurance support. Rick's Club American

Paula Eckhart

Oct 22, 2020

Report

Everyone is friendly and helpful. Jeannine always goes out of her way. I was recently able to purchase and take home my new car in large part due to her assistance.

Willow D.

Feb 02, 2020

Report

I have been using Coyle for my commercial and for my home for over 20 years, and I can clearly state that the staff at Coyle goes above and beyond. I can and have reached out to Coyle on weekends and after normal business hours and my calls are always taken or immediately returned along with being taken care of. As far as rates and overall knowledge of products Coyle always offers competitive and overall fair prices for products while explaining the benefits of these policies. They are clearly above and beyond the others.

John Egenes

Jan 27, 2020

Report

I've been with the Coyle agency for over 20 years and have been very happy with the level of professionalism and attention to detail. Jeannine is excellent at what she does and always a pleasure to deal with.

Pierre Bohemond

Mar 23, 2019

Report

I have worked with Coyle Insurance Agency for many years. Customer service unsurpassed! Responses are always within few hours. It's a pleasure working with the entire staff, they are very knowledgeable and caring.

Mary Araneo

Mar 20, 2019

Report

When my renewal came up in March, you found and offered me a much lower-cost replacement without me even asking. Local, personal service from a longtime business can't be beat!