No two homeowners are exactly alike. We know that you have specific needs whether you're trying to protect your family or business. We'll provide policies tailored to meet your needs. Work with a knowledgeable insurance agent that is committed to getting you the policy that matches your described needs. Our agents will walk you through all of your options and answer questions as your make your decision. We have been servicing the Tampa Bay area's insurance needs since 1971. Our team of 13 have extensive experience and can answer any questions you have about your insurance.
Follow us
Services
The Seibert Insurance Agency, an independent agency representing more than 100 top insurance companies, has been servicing the Tampa Bay area's insurance needs since 1971. Our team of 13 professionals provides life, personal or commercial automobile, professional liability, homeowners, rental, dwelling fire, business owners policies, commercial property or general liability insurance for almost 7,000 individuals and families and more than 500 businesses.
Let us help you find the car insurance you need at a price you can afford in Tampa, Florida. From hurricanes to sinkholes or lightning, we understand the unique risks associated with owning a home in Florida. If you rent an apartment, house or even a dorm room, you need renters insurance to protect you and your property.
Whether you are shopping for a new auto rate, want to switch companies or are confused about the insurance coverage you need, you've come to the right place. We'll give you rate comparisons, money saving tips, car insurance discounts and payment plan options to make your auto insurance buying decision easy.
When it comes to the largest investment most people ever make, it just makes sense to have the right protection in place. From hurricanes to sinkholes to lightning, we understand the unique risks associated with owning a Florida home. Companies offer different homeowner coverage alternatives so choosing the right policy means finding the right mix of options to meet your needs - that's where we come in.
Reviews (30)
Shawn Henson
Jun 06, 2022
Jimmie Willis
Jun 06, 2022
Three years ago when we started our business we contacted Seibert Insurance Agency referred by a very good friend and we have them since, our first experience was very helpful, professional, knowledgeable and caring, that is the reason that we still have them because we trust them and they are very prompt to respond our inquires. We recommend them very highly. Melissa Haught is very professional, helpful and caring every time that we need help with our policy.
Jim Waechter
May 30, 2022
I've been using the Siebert Insurance Agency for a several years. They are always extremely prompt and professional. My agent is Jennifer, and whenever I need to make a change or ask a question, she always responds as though I'm the most important customer in her portfolio, which I know I'm not. Whenever I deal with the Siebert Agency, I always feel that they have my best interests in mind; their customer service is outstanding.
Tim Driskell
May 28, 2022
Excellent service, as always with Seibert Insurance. Jennifer was my agent, and she did a ton of research in an effort to address my needs, and always kept me informed of her progress. I had a complicated situation, and took up a lot of her time, but she was able to get me exactly what I needed! Win-win for everyone!
Wayne McDaniel
May 24, 2022
Ryan Gniadek
May 13, 2022
Philip Kimrey
May 11, 2022
It was a pleasure talking to Jennifer! She was prompt with my quote and on top of things trying to find best rates and coverage. Where others wouldn't return my call she did. It means allot to feel like you have personal relationship with somebody who's looking after your best interest. We're moving from NC to Florida and we no nothing about insurance and laws there and Jennifer was patient when I was asking "dumb" questions. Highly recommend her and the agency! I had that in NC and want it in Florida. So far AAA rating!
Honest Hammer
May 09, 2022
Jessica Alessi Kim
May 05, 2022
Matt Marquardt
Dec 12, 2021
Jenna Carbone
Oct 30, 2021
Wow, such a positive experience with Jennifer Hagemeyer as our agent! We did not realize we were overpaying on our auto insurance policy until she provided us with a lower rate for BETTER coverage. Jennifer answered all of our questions with ease and the whole process was completely stress free for us. We will definitely be using her in the future when we need to obtain homeowners insurance. Highly recommend!
Anthony Karban
Oct 27, 2021
Mohamad Kaissi
Oct 27, 2021
Michael Planas
Oct 18, 2021
Maria Shaw & Tina Russell are a fantastic duo to work with. i have bought 3 businesses over the last 4 years and they have helped me every step of the way with valuable information about what type of coverages to have, how to handle claims, and necessary info for my employees. They are worth their weight in gold. Would recommend to anyone.
Melissa Filippone
Sep 19, 2021
I would give a million stars if I could - I was referred to Jennifer when I "thought" my house was going to be included in the flood zone remapping and once I received a letter that I was in a flood zone, Jennifer was very helpful in getting the policy completed. I appreciated the referral and definitely appreciate the help.
Susan Pope
Aug 01, 2021
I am pleased to write a review for the Seibert Insurance Agency and in particular our agent Jennifer Hagemeyer. Finding an agency that provides personalized and complete insurance services in the Tampa Bay Area has been a difficult task. I was particularly pleased when I contacted Seibert Insurance Agency and received a response from Jennifer so quickly.
She continues to respond timely and professionally and never fails to answer the most basic and/or difficult questions with patience and in a complete and knowledgeable manner. My husband and I look forward to using the Seibert Insurance Agency for all of our insurance needs and continuing to work with Jennifer in the future.
She continues to respond timely and professionally and never fails to answer the most basic and/or difficult questions with patience and in a complete and knowledgeable manner. My husband and I look forward to using the Seibert Insurance Agency for all of our insurance needs and continuing to work with Jennifer in the future.
Pedro Miller
Jul 22, 2021
In preparing for my move to Florida, I was able to connect with Jennifer H. from Seibert Insurance, based out of Tampa, and was extremely pleased with her professionalism and level of support. The quote she provided me with was more affordable than other providers in the area. Great service and I would highly recommend it.
Janesza Cardona
Jun 29, 2021
The Seibert Insurance Agency has exceeded our expectations. As a Office Administrator for Small Businesses I work with Insurance Agents often. I have worked with the good, and the bad. I can say that I never worked with GREAT insurance agents until I came across Seibert Insurance! Literally everyone that I have worked with from the office has been wonderful! Maria and Tina strive to make sure their customers needs are being met, even when all the odds are against them.
I am very pleased with their professionalism, customer service, and response times. Most importantly, I am pleased with how they always make sure that we are taken care of. No matter the circumstances. We are happy to have such great agents behind our business. I highly recommend them to anyone looking!
I am very pleased with their professionalism, customer service, and response times. Most importantly, I am pleased with how they always make sure that we are taken care of. No matter the circumstances. We are happy to have such great agents behind our business. I highly recommend them to anyone looking!
Bint A.
Mar 06, 2020
Being new to Florida by way of SF CA/bay area I really didn't know what to expect in my search for auto insurance but after almost exhausting my efforts I came across Seibert Insurance. Jennifer Hagemeyer and I connected - spoke at length and she addressed any questions and/or concerns I had in regards to being insured in Florida which helped in making it a fluid transition.
I would highly recommend Seibert Insurance. and that you would engage Jennifer directly as I found her to be very knowledgeable about the product pipeline (auto, home, etc), genuinely attentive that's coupled w/ a great client/customer rapport.
I would highly recommend Seibert Insurance. and that you would engage Jennifer directly as I found her to be very knowledgeable about the product pipeline (auto, home, etc), genuinely attentive that's coupled w/ a great client/customer rapport.
Matthew L.
Jan 15, 2020
Eileen C.
Nov 22, 2019
My husband and I were referred to Jennifer Hagemeyer by a friend after we expressed extreme frustration with our current insurance agent. With our previous agent, every time our policies hit renewal, our coverage options were changed "by the computer". We had to do a tremendous amount of footwork in order to get things fixed at least twice a year for the past 5 years. I'm not sure what we were actually paying our agent to do other than to inconvenience us and frustrate us to no end.
Our initial quotes for auto, homeowners, and an umbrella policy all came in much lower than what we were currently paying. I was very pleased. When I went to institute the policies and make payment with Jennifer, I wanted to keep my homeowners deductible at $1000 for hurricane, but this meant I would have to keep my current homeowners policy for a short while longer.
I would have to make one minor change with my current agent in order to do this. When I called my current agent's office, I was told I could not make changes to my policy until the renewal in eight months. This was going to cause an issue with my umbrella policy. Jennifer called my homeowners carrier herself and found out that I could in fact make the change anytime I wanted. Seibert is not currently a broker for this particular carrier, but I suspect they will be soon. Jennifer went above and beyond and made this transition so much easier for us to do.
When I actually did pay, the cost was even lower than our original quote saving us over $550 on our policies. We ended up with policies with higher coverage limits, more comprehensive coverage, lower deductibles and a greater savings than what we were currently paying.
Our initial quotes for auto, homeowners, and an umbrella policy all came in much lower than what we were currently paying. I was very pleased. When I went to institute the policies and make payment with Jennifer, I wanted to keep my homeowners deductible at $1000 for hurricane, but this meant I would have to keep my current homeowners policy for a short while longer.
I would have to make one minor change with my current agent in order to do this. When I called my current agent's office, I was told I could not make changes to my policy until the renewal in eight months. This was going to cause an issue with my umbrella policy. Jennifer called my homeowners carrier herself and found out that I could in fact make the change anytime I wanted. Seibert is not currently a broker for this particular carrier, but I suspect they will be soon. Jennifer went above and beyond and made this transition so much easier for us to do.
When I actually did pay, the cost was even lower than our original quote saving us over $550 on our policies. We ended up with policies with higher coverage limits, more comprehensive coverage, lower deductibles and a greater savings than what we were currently paying.
Debra C.
Apr 22, 2019
We recently moved to Tampa and needed all new insurance (auto, home, personal umbrella, etc). After reading lots of reviews, we chose Seibert. They shop best rates with reputable companies, doing all the leg work and paperwork. Jennifer Hagemeyer went beyond my expectations with sound advice, quick response times and excellent follow-up to be certain everything was in place for some time-sensitive issues we had. If you're shopping for insurance, check these folks out. You won't be disappointed!
Angelo D.
Mar 05, 2019
Melissa G.
Feb 01, 2019
Doug J.
Jun 22, 2018
J. C.
May 06, 2018
Makenna K.
Apr 10, 2018
Jen at Seibert was AMAZING. I moved to Tampa in September and was getting completely hosed by the State Farm agent I transferred to. Jen was able to save me $300 per month on my auto insurance with one phone call. Getting set up was extremely simple and she made sure everything was handled on my end. I really appreciate the work she did and the appreciation she had for my business.
Puja P.
Jan 20, 2018
Jennifer Hagemeyer was very knowledgeable when helping me select home owners coverage. She handled all my questions professionally and with a sense of urgency. As a first-time home buyer, she was very thorough in explaning policy options and provided a very competitive quote. It was a pleasure to work with her and i would highly recommend Seibert Insurance agency.
Jason N. Jody B.
Nov 22, 2017
We met Jennifer at a recent event and she was very polite. She called when she said she was going to call and managed to save us several hundred dollars a year on our car/motorcycle insurance. We are so glad we met her. She does exactly what she says she is going to do and is extremely polite in doing it. Great Job, Jenn, thanks.
Damian P.
Jun 15, 2016
When it comes to getting insurance, we did not realize how easy the process could be. We received great service and all our questions were well responded to. We were very confident in the services that Seibert could provide. Additionally, not only were their services outstanding, but their pricing was very competitive. We highly recommend Seibert Insurance Agency. Thank you!