Expertise in Auto, Home, Motorcycle, Boat, Recreational Vehicle, Business and Commercial Vehicles, Life, Health, Disability, Annuities, and Special Risks. Our goal is to make sure, absolutely sure, that what you pay for is what you dare not live without! A graduate of The Ohio State University and member of Trusted Choice, LUTCF with over 45 years of experience. Call John for a free quote today!.

Twitter profile

Update Share

About Us Report

Getting insurance should be a personalized experience. When you call Kalmbaugh Insurance Agency, there will be no prompts or hold times, you will always speak with a real licensed agent. We're here to make sure you're properly protected with a customized policy. Does a computer program generate this kind of personalized experience?

Team Report

Kerry is a licensed agent bringing real experience with insurance education to give our clients thoughtful and detailed policies. Ian Kalmbaugh is a marketing and video professional based in sunny Santa Monica, California.

Companies Report

Central Insurance Company, Auto-Owners Insurance Company, Liberty Mutual, Safeco, Progressive Insurance Company, John Hancock, Banner, Lloyds of London and Genworth to name a few. Auto-Owners is "Highest in Customer Satisfaction with the Auto Insurance Claims Experience, Five Years in a Row."

Aa

Jun 19, 2022

Report

Kalmbaugh Insurance has handled our insurance needs for many years. John always finds the best policy at the best price. They take a considerable amount of pride in helping their clients and I can't imagine trusting anyone else.

Royce Workman

May 26, 2022

Report

John and his team have been personalizing and customizing insurance needs for me before the terms became buzzwords. It's the only way they know how to operate. They just plain make it easy for all aspects of insuring your assets.

Nilendu Gupta

May 15, 2022

Report

I have worked with John Kalmbaugh and his team as a customer for over 30 years. Excellent customer service and a very caring group of folks!

Dean Mathewson

May 13, 2022

Report

Kerry was very clear, patient and helpful, explaining the benefits and answering my questions. She was also able to find me some additional discounts.

Thememethod

May 06, 2022

Report

The professionalism of this agency is 1000 steps above the rest. I called just because I had a few questions for the young lady before going out of town and ended up saving money on my policy! The best in town.

Shawna Jones

Apr 25, 2022

Report

Kerry and her father have always been my go to insurance people. You cannot begin to find a more honest and thorough agency in the Columbus area!

Bloody PopcornTV

Apr 22, 2022

Report

Insurance agent Kerry Kalmbaugh has helped me save a lot of money with my insurance and was incredibly helpful. I highly recommend her and Kalmbaugh Insurance.

April Zobel

Apr 11, 2022

Report

Excellent customer service and attention to detail. The whole team is a pleasure to work with and saved me money on all my policies.

Jim Sutliff

Apr 07, 2022

Report

I have used Kalmbaugh Insurance for 40 years. They do an outstanding job of servicing their customers and finding the right insurance for your needs.

Robert Hughes

Feb 21, 2022

Report

John and the agency staff are knowledgeable, fast and friendly. They helped our contracting business reach our fullest potential with good coverage.

Susan Whittaker

Mar 22, 2021

Report

We have been with John Kalmbaugh for 25 years and regularly send then referrals

J. Zhgt

May 05, 2019

Report

They're amazing, really great customer service kind and helpful. Tonya and Margaret are awesome and will help you with anything.