Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Bay Agency Insurance Group Founded in 1985, Bay Agency Insurance Group is an independent agency located in Rumson, New Jersey. Through the years, Bay Agency's knowledgeable agents and service representatives have offered unsurpassed personal service to each and every one of it's clients.

Bay Marine, a specialty division of Bay Agency, has been offering their marine insurance clients top-notch service paralleled with unmatched knowledge of the marine insurance and boating environment.When your business, family or boat is faced with an insurance challenge, count on the Bay Agency to safely navigate you through to more familiar waters.
Services
As a business owner, you need the same kinds of insurance coverages for the car you use in your business as you do for a car used for personal travel -- liability, collision and comprehensive, medical payments (known as personal injury protection in some states) and coverage for uninsured motorists.
Why do you need insurance for your boat or personal watercraft? You'll enjoy the water even more when you're not worried about the safety of yourself, your passengers or your investment. If you're in an accident or your watercraft is stolen, it costs money, often a lot of money, to fix or replace it.
What is auto insurance? Auto insurance protects you against financial loss if you have an accident. It is a contract between you and the insurance company. You agree to pay the premium and the insurance company agrees to pay your losses as defined in your policy. Liability coverage pays for your legal responsibility to others for bodily injury or property damage.
Why do you need insurance for your motorcycle? You'll enjoy being out on the open road even more when you're not worried about the safety of yourself, your passengers or your investment. If you're in an accident or your motorcycle is stolen, it costs money, often a lot of money, to fix or replace it.
Reviews (13)
Write a Review
Cathy Gallagher
May 18, 2022
We have been clients with the Bay Agency for over 20 years and with a few different boats. They are great! Specifically, Linda Shannon, my "go to" at the Bay Agency. She's extremely responsive, very knowledgeable, and pleasant to deal with. It's the staff there that keeps me as a customer. Kudos to the Bay Agency!
John Denza
Mar 28, 2022
Jennifer Truglia at Bay Agency was excellent to work with in securing a policy for my home. She is extremely diligent and went above and beyond to ensure she found us the best rate. It was a very smooth process and I would definitely use this agency going forward and recommend it to all.
Stephen
Mar 12, 2022
Bay Agency is an exceptional agency. It consistently delivers great policies at the most competitive prices, solid advice and easy, friendly and responsive customer service - thank you Jennifer. We've moved all our home, auto and excess liability to carriers Bay works with. We've dealt with many of the large carriers and other agencies, but Bay is by far the most experiences and professional. We continue to recommend them to our friends and family.
Travis Truglia
Jul 24, 2021
Professional office that makes sure you're covered from your auto, home and commercial. Highly recommend!
Jennie Albanese
Dec 24, 2020
Bay Agency and their staff are the best. From start to finish we had a great experience with them. I would recommend them to everyone I know.
Edward Winder
Jul 02, 2020
There are alot of insurance companies around, Bay Agency and their staff are PROS. Great customer service and top shelf communication. I thank you!
Michael
Mar 03, 2020
Fantastic group of people. I have been using them for a few years for my boat. They are on top of it, friendly, best prices and coverage. Nice work!
Gerard Cudzil
Jan 01, 2020
UPDATED NOV '19: Once again Bay Agency comes through. My insurance was recently cancelled from an insurance company with a complicated insurance policy. Bay Agency and their qualified professional agents were able to secure a policy for me with better coverage - Simply Awesome! Thank You again, Bay! Best Agency Hands-down for your boat insurance needs.

They help with home, car & commercial insurance and provide competitive quotes. Friendly & Knowledge agents. Everyone at the agency is Amazing! I can't say enough of how helpful and pleasant everyone is from the owner to the receptionist and everyone in between. Give them a shout, you won't regret it.
Chelsea Ryan
Nov 11, 2018
The staff at Bay Agency are the best and easy to work with. They know their stuff inside and out and such a great team to work with! Such an Incredible experience!
Lucille Cudzil
Nov 06, 2018
Highly recommend Bay Agency. The staff is extremely friendly, knowledgeable and patient. Thumbs Up
Jr Moro
Jan 18, 2018
Bay Agency can & should be your one stop for all your insurance needs ( home, cars, motorcycles & boats). Brian & his staff provide fair quotes & excel in customer service. Give them a call & know you will be in good hands.
Chris Gallagher
Nov 16, 2017
Professional and knowledgeable. They are our go to agency for all our marine and marina insurance. There is no better group. When we got devastated by Hurricane Sandy, Brian and his group were there the next day to help us recover.
William Truszkowski
May 29, 2017
Excellent staff. My agent Amy is excellent. It is hard these days just to get a call back wheb someone says they will but this co. is right on top of what they do and they have excellent communication skills. My boat policy is also less than half of what I was quoted by the insurer of 2 cars and a motorcycle.