Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
First Choice Agency Cheapest Car Insurance, Commercial Insurance, Flood, General Liability & Homeowners Insurance in Queens, Brooklyn, Lindenhurst, Jamaica, Amityville, Babylon, Deer Park, Farmingdale, Massapequa, NY, and Surrounding Areas. Low rates, Low or NO deposit, E-Z payments, Instant coverage Auto Insurance for every driver, age & vehicle (Tickets, Accidents, Permits, Suspended Licenses OK).

We know you need affordable rates on quality insurance coverage, so we take the time to get to know you, your needs and to evaluate your circumstance before we offer or write a policy for you.
Services
About Auto, Business, Flood, General Liability & Home Insurance from First Choice Insurance Agency: Serving Brooklyn, Queens, Jamaica, Amityville, Babylon, Deer Park, Farmingdale, Lindenhurst, Massapequa NY. First Choice Insurance has been providing a full range of complete services for personal and commercial insurance since 1987.
Home Insurance, Homeowners Insurance from First Choice Insurance Agency: Serving Amityville, Babylon, Deer Park, Farmingdale, Lindenhurst, Brooklyn, Massapequa, NY, and Surrounding Areas. Homeowner's policies can provide coverage for the replacement value of your home, other structures on your property, personal property indoors, subsidize temporary housing costs while your home is being repaired, and a host of other liabilities.
Flood damage to your waterfront home, or home or business anywhere in Long Island and the NYC area can be caused by a number of factors including rapid precipitation accumulation, broken water pipes or damage from a snowfall. With changing weather patterns, water accumulation can occur for reasons previously thought not likely.
Cheapest Car Insurance and Auto Insurance in Lindenhurst, Brooklyn, Amityville, Babylon, Deer Park, Farmingdale, Massapequa, NY, and Surrounding Areas. Whether you're a seasoned driver or a young driver with a new license, First Choice Insurance has the right policy for you. We can help you determine what coverage options are best for your insurance needs, because we know how important it is for you to get options at rates you can afford and with deductibles that are reasonable.As your independent insurance agent, we do all the comparisons for you.
Reviews (7)
Write a Review
Cynthia Finney Brewster
Jun 05, 2021
First Choice Ins was very helpful, also very friendly. There Insurance rates are unbelievably LOW! I pay half the price that Gieco was charging me. I wish I knew about them yrs ago. I could have saved 1,000 of dollars. Google them you won't be disappointed
Popping Shrimp
Jan 09, 2020
Kelly was awesome! So pleasant and friendly and helpful until the very end. First choice saved me $300 a month on insurance! Couldn't be happier!
N. Duncan
Oct 03, 2019
I had the most amazing experience with Melissa. She was very nice and got me a great rate in just a few minutes. Best Agent I spoke with and I called several companies! I will recommend her to anyone looking for car insurance!
Michael Neumayer
May 10, 2019
Great Office-Cathy is a pleasure to deal with-Highly Recommend!
Kelly Walz
Feb 22, 2017
Was with a gecko until First Choice saved me a ton of money on my car insurance! would recommend them to anyone and everyone. my friend also has his business insurance with them and they helped him tremendously.
Kim Schlie
Aug 30, 2016
Absolutely the best place to go for insurance the people there are friendly and very helpful they saved me so much money I'm referring my friends to them thank you first choice for saving me a fortune
C. Brunetta
May 10, 2015
Love this place! Friendly, helpful and affordable. They saved me $1200 on my auto insurance. I've recommended some friends and family to them and they've done right by everyone!