Brotherhood Mutual provides innovative insurance coverage and risk management resources specifically designed for ministries. Brotherhood Mutual's property insurance offers protection for physical items-from songbooks to steeples. Other carriers might offer coverage for less money, but it's not the same service as we get from Brotherhood Mutual. Quality and price are both important.We get a good value for our needs. Thank you for your interest in Brotherhood Mutual. We appreciate the opportunity to provide your church or other ministry with an insurance quote and will reply to your request as soon as possible.
Follow us
Services
Because we are a mutual company, our heart is in supporting and serving each other. Like you, Brotherhood Mutual has a purpose that rises above brick and mortar. Our employees and agents demonstrate our core values and carry out the company's mission of Advancing the Kingdom by Serving the Church. If you reach a milestone, we celebrate with you.
Because we've been insuring churches for more than 100 years, we understand the unique needs of ministry. Every year, we work with thousands of Christian churches and related ministries, schools, camps, and colleges. Our insurance can be tailored to fit any ministry, large or small. We share your passion for ministry.
Brotherhood Mutual insures America's churches and related ministries. We have for more than 100 years. From our perspective, insurance is more than a commercial endeavor. It's a platform to accomplish our mission: to help America's churches and related ministries build the Kingdom. We do that by providing quality property and liability insurance coverage, custom-designed to help churches and related ministries do their work safely and effectively.In serving the church, we will uphold the Biblical values upon which the company was founded.
When you choose Brotherhood Mutual Insurance you join hands with Christian ministries across America, encircling the Church and protecting it from harm. Together, you rebuild churches, restore ministries, and renew hope in the wake of life's storms. You carry one another's burdens. That's the power of choosing Brotherhood Mutual, a company who exists to advance the Kingdom by serving the church.
Reviews (9)
Chad Gramling
May 27, 2022
Mark Whipple
Nov 05, 2021
Laurel Swanson
Jun 13, 2021
Nclay
Jan 16, 2021
Vicki Counts
Jan 03, 2021
I am sad to say that we are looking elsewhere for coverage. I get no communication from BHM regarding our claim that has been open since MARCH, it is now mid July. I have been given nothing but excuses. Our premium is due next month and they will expect payment on time but cannot address our claim. We have been customers for 20 years and am just left so disappointed and saddened with their service.
William Blakley
Dec 08, 2020
We have been with Brotherhood over 9 years. If you have an issue and you can't afford it but are trying to raise the funds for it, they will drop you quickly. They do not work well with churches that are struggling. Of course COVID-19 (2020) was a rough year for many but Brotherhood gave no wiggle room to replace any issues regarding our roofing at our church. They basically said we know you want have the roof done by this date so go ahead and consider the policy canceled on that date. Unprofessional. No graceful. Not Christlike.
Greg Miles
May 30, 2020
Our house burnt down a few years ago that was apart of our ministry. They committed fraud and refused to pay, saying they would keep appealing the case so we would never get payed. Almost put us out of business as we had to cover the past mortgage on the house that burnt down and then additional expenses to replace the house, as it was a huge part of our ministry. 0/5 stars if I could, go to State Farm they won't screw you over.
Nelson Eagle
Dec 19, 2019
The Brotherhood payroll service was recommended to me in 2018. I tried it for 1 quarter and changed to ADP. Their service was TERRIBLE. There was no help screens accessible, so one had to contact them every time a question about how to do something came up. When I changed to ADP, ADP picked up all the payroll wage and withholding information as YTD info for our employees. They doubled up on W-2 reports, so our employees got notices for tax audits due to unpaid taxes. STAY AWAY FROM BROTHERHOOD!
Thai Radin
Apr 25, 2018
