Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Colonial Insurance Agency is committed to improving the quality of our community by insuring your life's hard work. Setting a standard of excellence, our professional staff will help you understand your current and future risk exposures by building a lifelong relationship. Our clients can be confident in the organization's proven stability. We are dedicated to continuous improvement through the use of technology in order to provide the most comprehensive and cost effective solutions. We are here to help!
Follow us
Services
We ARE committed to the needs of our clientele by providing a variety of insurance solutions to protect against the unexpected in life. Our agency listens to and educates our clientele and prospective clients about what insurance solutions best align with their lifestyles, the assets they have accumulated, and the everyday exposures that they face.
Your home is a huge investment, protect it. Whether it's a one-room condo, a three-flat or a suburban "mansion, " you can protect your home against theft, fire, lawsuits, weather damage and other covered losses with homeowner's insurance. There are many options of what home insurance can cover on your property and it can be overwhelming.
Getting into a car accident might be the furthest thing from your mind, but it's best to be prepared for anything. Colonial Insurance Agency will help you choose the right policy for your "wheels" - from the smallest sports car to the largest SUV (motorcycles and RVs, too). We will provide you with rates from multiple insurance companies to help you shop for the best combination of price and coverage.
Significant accidents or unfortunate events can quickly exhaust a policy's coverage leaving you personally liable for the other party's property damage, medical costs, lost wages and more. Umbrella insurance provides an extra level of liability coverage. If you already have your home and auto policies with Colonial Insurance Agency, we can write umbrella liability limits of $1 million or $2 million. Your independent agent can determine whether umbrella insurance is appropriate for you and help you meet our underwriting requirements.
Reviews (15)
Write a Review
Diana J.
Jun 20, 2022
Don MacLeod has been a blessing to work with over the past 15+ years! As a single mom, I was trying to navigate the insurance system (*gulp*) and I found Don to be knowledgeable, supportive, kind and efficient. He was a word-of-mouth referral. He was always there to answer questions and still is! You send an email after-hours, you get an immediate system reply!

He follows up when he says he will. Oh and his son Dan has been helping me lately and he is a chip off the old block! (I'm not calling you an "old block" Don, but you know what I mean! ) If you need insurance of any kind--you'd be foolish not to use Colonial! They are the type of people that if they can't help you (which is likely impossible), they would find someone who can. I have NO doubt! Thanks Don, Dan and the Colonial Insurance staff! We love you at the Joy house! (Both of my sons, now adults, are with Colonial Insurance as well!)
Tucson Trail Investments
Jun 20, 2022
Dan, Jack and the rest of the Colonial Team have been a great partner for not only our business but personal insurance as well. They are quick to respond and steer you in the right direction providing you with the proper type and amount of insurance. Building business is about partnership and we are glad we found Colonial Insurance Agency!
Theresa Pivotto
Jun 19, 2022
Shopping for insurance is something we never do very often but should. One call to Colonial Insurance is all it took because they represent multiple companies and found us the best deal. Wish I would have done it sooner. They are very friendly and professional. Thank you Jack!
Eric Kovacevich
Jun 18, 2022
I always feel assured Colonial has my best interest in picking proper coverage for me and my business. Straight shooters with no sales pressure!
Randy & Ashley Durham
Jun 17, 2022
Jack has been a Godsend for our insurance needs, helping us cover everything from our home to our car, our business and our RV. When we first made the switch to Colonial, Jack actually realized we weren't even properly covered for our farm with our previous insurance company and he absolutely was instrumental in protecting our family.
Michael Cappozzo
Jun 17, 2022
Jack made switching insurance providers simple and painless! Unrivaled service - I know when I refer someone to Colonial, they will have the same experience I did.
Jason Franzke
Jun 16, 2022
I worked with Jack and he was great at explaining everything to me. We got a great deal through a phenomenal company and couldn't be happier!
Rishabh Sachdeva
May 27, 2022
Can't say enough good things about the service we received from Jack and team. My wife and I were hesitant to switch insurance companies, we had become comfortable with our previous provider. We are very glad we made the switch! Jack was very knowledgeable and ensured we received top notch service at comparable rates. We had a lot of questions and he was very thorough and timely in providing responses. This confirmed we were going to be in good hands and would 100% recommend to anyone else trying to make the switch. Happy to stand behind team Colonial!
Jeff Ludowissi
Apr 23, 2022
Dan and the rest of the Colonial staff are incredibly helpful. They are responsive to questions and are there for you when you need them most. When my wife was in a car accident Dan made sure we were taken care of without any issues. He was reassuring, knowledgeable, caring and made sure that we didn't have extra stress of dealing with insurance payments. If you're looking for an agency that has your back colonial is the way to go! 10/10 would recommend!
Thomas Vrabel
Jan 19, 2022
The agents are always exceptionally quick to respond to questions, needs, whatever. Very knowledgeable and give me options and rates that are competitive and don't just keep rising every year. Have home, auto, RV and umbrella insurance through Colonial Insurance Agency.
Mike Parish
Oct 17, 2021
I am fairly ignorant when it comes to insurance matters. It's one of those things that as long as I have it, I'm fine. When I was getting a new car, I was concerned about my coverage and making sure my vehicle was well protected. Dan McLeod helped me throughout the entire process. He found a policy that fit my needs and budget and made sure I understood what I was paying for. He also helped me cancel my previous vehicle and set up my new one. I'm very thankful I had this experience and would tell anyone to work with Colonial.
Chad Donohoue
Feb 14, 2021
I can't say enough about this agency! They are extremely knowledgeable and most important, they are very trustworthy. They don't take advantage of you by making sure you are covered for what you need to be but they don't sell you what you don't need. Highly recommend!
Cayla Donohoue
Oct 20, 2020
We were exceptionally happy with the service we received after talking with Dan. Not only do we feel we got the best rates, he was friendly professional and made us feel well taken care of. Thanks Dan!
Ann
Jan 07, 2017
We have been with Don and Colonial Insurance for over 25 years. He helped us out when our driving records were not so great and found us the best rates available. He has always gotten us the best rates and made recommendations on how to get even better rates. Will never leave them!
Amanda Angove
Oct 20, 2013
Mark and his team are amazing! They always seem to beat out the competition and make the transition to a new policy or changes to a policy simple. My family has used Colonial Insurance for over 20 years for everything from Auto, Motorcycle, watercraft, homeowners, renters and umbrella policies. We always feel well informed on the products offered and are able to make a decision easily with Mark and his teams help. I highly recommend Colonial Insurance for anyone with insurance needs!