Since its inception, our agency has been working with exceptional insurance companies like Acuity, Safeco, AAA, and Progressive to save our customers money. We shop for our customers and negotiate on their behalf to shed a pleasant light on the insurance industry. Insurance Outfitters had its start in 1957 when our agency founder Willard Geiger left his farm and became an agent over on Western Road. Since that day we've strived to live up to the home grown qualities that our agency had from the beginning - now into our third generation.

Update Share

Services Report

We've got all your insurance needs covered: From personal to business protection and everything in between. Don't hesitate to give us a call or stop in when you have some extra time. Our average customer in 2015 saved $650.

Eddie DeLuisa

Jan 19, 2021

Report

These guys are great! This is a family agency and there just very freindly and personable. There office in Cedarburg is a fun experience to be inside of, its like being inside a log cabin in the north woods, very cozy and folksy. You'll like doing biz with this agency. Ed

Daren Olson

Jun 01, 2020

Report

Saved money came through with outstanding service when called upon. USAA convert.

Kate P.

Mar 04, 2019

Report

We took a Dave Ramsey course in saving money. We never knew how much it would change our life. Like seeking out a new insurance carrier. My husband had heard of these guys so we decided to check it out. They are awesome. We got more coverage in all areas with an overall cost savings. And so easy to work with too. I have recommended to others.

Tiffany

Jan 10, 2018

Report

Very nice and helpful people. We were made to feel comfortable and the woman there was very nice to my little boy. We trust them with our insurance needs!

Robin T.

Nov 20, 2017

Report

Great family-run business that offers caring service. They also don't forget about you after you've signed a policy. They saved us money by combining our home and auto policies, eliminated unnecessary coverage and helped us navigate through our multiple teen drivers.