As a Trusted Choice insurance agency, we offer you choice - a choice in products and companies. We have access to a diverse selection of financially strong and secure companies such as The Hartford, AARP, AAA, Blue Cross, Erie, Mercury, MetLife, Progressive, and many more. At Faller Insurance Agency, you'll have a personal and professional licensed agent handling your account.

You won't have to speak with a different person each time you call. We also assist you when you have a claim, guiding you through the process and assisting you when you need it.

Update Share

About Us Report

Faller Insurance Agency has been in business since 1948. We specialize in providing individuals, families, and businesses with quality insurance products at competitive prices. We are your "go to" for all your insurance needs, having expertise in all types of insurance, including Obamacare. If you own a small businesses, we will construct a plan for your specific needs.

Get a Quote Report

Looking for coverage? Choose Faller Insurance Agency for affordable rates, great products, and great service. We offer a wide range of products to meet the needs of individuals, families and businesses. We represent many insurance companies including AAA, Erie Insurance Company, Hartford AARP, Mercury, MetLife, Progressive, and more.

File a Claim Report

If you need to report a claim, please call us at (847)430-3342 during normal business hours. You can fax your police report or estimates to (847)430-3328. After hours or in the event of an emergency, you can contact your insurance company directly.

Make a Payment Report

You can quickly and easily make a payment on your insurance policy. For all other other carriers, please choose your payment method and fill in the payment form. Faller Insurance Agency will process the payment on your behalf.

Paul Satera

Mar 17, 2022

Report

I have been doing business for years with Faller and have never been disappointed!

Melanie Simonsen

Feb 13, 2022

Report

I needed health insurance and Maggie was great! She is personable, helpful and explained everything that I needed to know. I would recommend her!

Cynthia Cwik

Dec 29, 2021

Report

My agent, Maggiei Nessim managed my transfer to Erie Insurance for my autos, homeowners and umbrella policies seamlessly. She responds to my phone calls or emails quickly. Maggie explains the need and reasoning to insure property at recommended limits.

Chris Guza

Nov 09, 2021

Report

Anytime insurance comes up in a conversation I tell people about Maggie and Faller Insurance Agency. She is the best at finding great insurance coverage for your needs, be it home, auto or health.

Linda N. Smentek

Oct 22, 2021

Report

This is a super friendly, very professional company. I was able to come home with a printout comparing suggested programs!

Jrj Junk

Sep 06, 2021

Report

I highly recommend Maggie Nessim, CIC and the Faller Insurance Agency. For over 20 years I was an Independent insurance agent writing commercial lines insurance. When it was time to choose an agent for my own auto/home/umbrella coverage I chose Maggie Nessim. As a fellow CIC I knew she would provide excellent coverage, great options to keep my premiums low and outstanding service. She's professional, proficient and very friendly.

Greg Tampengco

Aug 07, 2021

Report

Maggie and Ryan are very knowledgeable, prompt, efficient and friendly, always finding us the best deal. I look forward to a long relationship with Maggie/Ryan at Faller Insurance Agency. Thank you for everything.

Kristi Adachi

Mar 07, 2021

Report

Faller Insurance is a very well run business. The President, Maggie Nessim is professional, yet friendly Her assistant Ryan is terrific at getting the paperwork done. They handle several of my properties, all with different needs. She has found the companies most suitable for each one at the best prices. You're never going to be disappointed if you hire them!

Jennifer M.

Dec 23, 2020

Report

Maggie is amazing. She goes above and beyond. I can't highly recommend her enough. She's creative, thorough and gets her clients the best rates without compromising coverage.

Kiran Patel

Dec 28, 2019

Report

My son have car and home insurance with Maggie. Now I have my car Insurance with her, very nice and helpful person. I recomend her for car or home insurance to everyone. Thank you Maggie.

Ken D.

Feb 11, 2018

Report

Faller Insurance is terrific. Maggie is incredibly well-informed, and she and her staff are highly responsive. I feel like they honestly work hard to meet my needs. It's nice to have the feeling that they've got my back, plus I don't have to pay extra for the personal service.

Sheldon S.

Feb 06, 2018

Report

I switched to Faller after many years at Farmers. Maggie strives to find the best rates from reputable companies for her clients.

Jennifer Miller

Dec 21, 2016

Report

I've been working with Maggie for years. I have my car and homeowners insurance through her. She is very conscientious and really works hard to find not only the best rate, but the best coverage for her clients. I wouldn't go anywhere else.

Carole M.

Dec 14, 2014

Report

Maggie Nessim is first-rate in navigating and explaining all the current insurance options. Personable, patient, and understanding, she helped me get the coverage I needed, and when questions arose she greatly simplified what might have been a complicated and messy situation. She's my hero!