Ellington Mutual was formed by the early settlers of Stephensville in Outagamie County. Owning and managing their own local company provided these courageous people with a better way to insure themselves at a lower cost. Now over 140 years later, our policyholder owners still hold to those principals. Protection is the essence of why people purchase insurance.When something unforeseen happens people need their loss restored quickly and efficiently. At Ellington Mutual our local Agents and Staff work hard everyday to ensure that happens.
Follow us
Services
A. Your Agent has access to a computer program that can calculate the cost to replace your home in today's market. We recommend that you contact your Agent on an annual basis (or immediately if you have completed any additions or remodeling), to make sure that your property is adequately insured. A.
You have taken the first step by filing a loss report with your agent. A claims representative will contact you soon at the telephone number you provided to arrange an appointment. Please provide all available contact numbers including home, cell and work. If you are not able to stay in your home, please share your temporary address and phone number with your agent or claims representative so we can stay in touch with you. In a disaster situation, a team of claims representative will work in your area.
It will depend on a number of factors: what coverage you purchased, what caused the loss or damage, and what property was lost or damaged, to name a few. If you're wondering if a particular loss or damage would be covered, contact your agent. Contact your local Better Business Bureau for information about the contractors you're considering.
Reviews (7)
Jen Dilge
Aug 22, 2021
Brook Haasl
Dec 24, 2020
Marla Jones
Nov 06, 2019
Mary Lou Marshall
Mar 12, 2018
I had paid premiums to another Wisconsin insurer for 25 years and immediately after they paid for my 1 and only claim they cancelled my coverage. I moved my insurance to Ellington Mutual after I saw how they treated my daughter and family when they lost their house and most of their belongings to a fire. The settlement for their losses was substantial, they were paid very quickly and very fairly.
Since being insured with them we have had claims for storm damage on our home and property damage caused by a neighbor to our rental property. They immediately sent someone with expertise and empathy to evaluate the damage. We were pleased with the settlements and we quickly received compensation for repairs. I couldn't be more pleased.
Since being insured with them we have had claims for storm damage on our home and property damage caused by a neighbor to our rental property. They immediately sent someone with expertise and empathy to evaluate the damage. We were pleased with the settlements and we quickly received compensation for repairs. I couldn't be more pleased.
Eric Uecke
Jan 19, 2018
Sara Klimpke-Buttry
Dec 21, 2017
Jason Myerchin
Oct 29, 2017
Just bought a house and they dropped me before I made my first mortgage payment. Just a letter in the mail, no phone call. Dropped for very minor reasons that were fixed within 10 minutes. I called and talked to Howard Schwartz. Very rude and condescending. Said there was no chance of keeping the coverage through them. Told me to talk to my agent. He was no help.
